Both in the Okinawa Charter on the Global Information Society, and in
planning meetings and the first plenary meeting of the Digital Opportunity Task
Force (DOT Force), considerable emphasis has been placed on the importance of a
broad, participatory approach to the DOT Force's deliberations, securing the
views, participation and consensus of a wide range of stakeholders on a global
level. The presence of representatives of several key constituencies on the DOT
Force itself facilitates the consultation process. However, in order to maximize
effective outreach in the short time available, and to assure coordination and
synergy among the outreach efforts of DOT Force members and the Secretariat,
this paper suggests a framework, division of labor, and process for organizing
the consultation process.
Basic Principles
The proposed approach to DOT Force consultations is rooted in several basic
principles:
- DOT Force members should have a lead role in planning and organizing
outreach efforts to their own constituencies, and should commit time and
resources as appropriate to organize such efforts, in coordination with the
Secretariat;
- in order to facilitate aggregation of the inputs from the full range of
consultations, the Secretariat should develop, in cooperation with DOT Force
members, a suggested common template of issues and questions for these
consultations;
- the Secretariat should focus its own consultation efforts in those areas
where there are particular gaps, as identified in the attached matrix;
- the Secretariat may, in consultation with DOT Force members, accept offers
from other networks or organizations to organize, at their own expense and
initiative, further consultations that would provide input into the DOT
Force process, particularly to fill the gaps discussed above;
- within the existing time and resource constraints, the consultative
process should be as broad and participatory as feasible, reaching out to a
wide array of stakeholders in both developed and developing countries;
- particular efforts should be made to secure the participation of those,
especially in developing countries, who traditionally have limited access to
consultations of this sort, especially the poor;
- clarity about the objectives, scope and limitations of the consultations
is paramount; it should be understood by all that these consultations are inputs
into the DOT Force's deliberations, but that the conclusions and
recommendations from any particular consultation will not automatically be
included in the DOT Force's report;
- the consultation process should take advantage whenever possible of
already-scheduled meetings and conferences rather than devoting time and
resources to organizing new meetings for this purpose;
- this consultative process should make maximum feasible use of information
and communication technologies both to increase scope and participation and
to reduce the need for specially-convened face-to-face consultative
meetings.
Roles and Responsibilities
The Secretariat is responsible, in consultation with the G8 Presidency, for
overall coordination of the consultation process and for sharing information
among DOT Force members about consultation activities. The Secretariat should
begin consulting immediately with DOT Force members about their own plans and
priorities for consultation within the framework of the attached
"consultation matrix", and the resources (human and financial) that
they are able to mobilize to carry forward these consultations. The Secretariat
should also prepare a draft "template" of questions and issues for
consultations, for comment and review by DOT Force members by December 15.
DOT Force members will be expected to keep the Secretariat informed of their
own consultation activities, so as to maximize synergies among the various
consultations and reduce overlap and duplication of effort, given the severe
time constraints faced by the Task Force. DOT Force members are free to define
the scope and nature of the consultations they will conduct within their areas
of lead responsibility in the attached matrix, with the understanding that the
Secretariat and other DOT Force members may, in consultation with the relevant
member, organize other consultations that fill gaps in the consultation process.
The Secretariat will focus its own consultation efforts in those areas
identified in the attached matrix where there are no DOT Force members in a lead
role. The Secretariat should report back to the DOT Force by January 5, 2001
with a detailed matrix of those consultations being organized by DOT Force
members and by the Secretariat. At this point, the Secretariat may, in
consultation with the Presidency, suggest additional "gap-filling"
consultation activities that the Secretariat or DOT Force members may wish to
organize, or that other organizations or networks might be invited to organize
on behalf of the DOT Force.
Information about all DOT Force-related consultations, including written
reports/summaries as available and the archives of all public electronic
consultations, should be available in a timely manner on a public DOT Force
website maintained by the Secretariat.